Here are the differences between club soda vs seltzer, carbonated water vs sparkling water, and every variation therein: Carbonated Water. The calories content may not be the only way to distinguish tonic water from club soda. “I personally love soda as a mixer with most spirits,” she says. Club Soda vs Tonic Water. Sure, the bubbly drink starts out as carbonated water , and then quinine — a bitter alkaloid once used to treat malaria — is added. Seltzer water is nothing more than water with a little injection of CO2. For more about tonic water, read our more comprehensive post here Several varieties of commercial tonic syrups are also produced, which allow a drinker to customize their preferred level of quinine flavor. Jim Vorel is a Paste staff writer and resident liquor geek. Quinine has a distinctly bitter, mineral flavor, which is balanced in almost all commercial tonic waters by added sugars or sweeteners. Club soda may seem like the same thing as pure seltzer water at first glance, but this is water that has been enhanced by the manufacturer with additional minerals. Quinine, when found in small doses in tonic water, is safe to consume. During Hubert’s happy hour, which offers $5 gin and tonics made with Cascade Tonic from 4pm to 6pm, Hemsworth says it’s clear more people lately are ordering gin and sodas, which Hubert makes with Cascade Soda Water. In the end, it’s just a matter of taste. Is “club soda” really a different product than seltzer? Nowadays, quinine is used to give that bitter flavor to tonic water. In fact, “tonic water” is a bit of a misnomer. Today, sugar is often added to this type of water, and the amount of quinine has been greatly reduced. But if you're sick, chugging tonic water won't do much beyond keeping you hydrated. Tonic water and soda water may look the same, but the two drinks are actually quite different. The first tonic waters contained powdered quinine, sugar, and soda water. Yes, just like tonic water (see our previous post: Perrier vs Tonic Water) both Perrier water and soda water are carbonated. That’s because many manufacturers often add high-fructose corn syrup or natural sugar to the beverage to improve the taste. Compare Water to Tonic water by vitamins and minerals using the only readable nutrition comparison tool. There’s lightly fizzing bitter tonic water, a frequent foil for gin.Sparkling mineral water has subtle flavors that range from salty to metallic. This gives tonic water a balance between bitterness, somewhat resinous notes and corresponding sweetness, which pairs very well with liquor such as gin in the ubiquitous G&T. But the truth is that each possesses unique qualities and uses that set them apart from each other. He seemed to believe it worked, too, so I suppose that it still had enough quinine to be a little helpful. Seltzer vs Club Soda vs Tonic Water vs Sparkling Water Published: January 2, 2020 Updated: January 3, 2020 Matt Lehmann All four of the waters in the title are carbonated, but they vary based on how they are made and used. And what exactly makes “tonic” so different? Tonic water contains quinine, which is an all-natural crystalline alkaloid.Quinine has many medicinal properties including analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects. But the concentration of quinine in tonic drinks is significantly below the levels found in anti-malaria drugs, effectively busting that myth. The tonic water that was once used to cure malaria is slightly different from what can be purchased today. However, it also is the least healthy. These siphons could instantly create carbonated water, which was often served on its own or with strong alcohol such as scotch. In its base form, however, traditional seltzer water (such as La Croix Pure) is simply water + bubbles, and that’s it. Both tonic and soda water have an interesting history, but they are only tempting to one's tastebuds if they are used correctly. “And tonic water adds a pleasant earthy bitterness and spice.” Seltzer and club soda are popular drink-alone flat water alternatives, but all three are majors in the cocktail world. This can make it a good choice in mixology when only carbonation is desired, but it’s arguably less commonly used for this purpose than club soda (which we’ll talk about next). More often than not, those who enjoy tonic water enjoy it for its distinctive taste. Tonic is the most unique and distinctive of carbonated waters, and by far the easiest to identify from taste alone. To help you decide the right water to choose, you have to first understand the different types of carbonated water available on the market. Does diet tonic water that contains quinine count as part of the daily water intake? The key difference is that tonic contains quinine, which introduces the bitter element in the drink and sugar. © 2020 Paste Media Group. This is the same method used for getting the bubbles into your favorite cans of pop. What are differences compared to Tonic Water. Club Soda was first produced in the late eighteenth century as a soft drink. That makes club soda the go-to for many bartenders when it comes to adding bubbles in mixed drinks or cocktails, and the expected addition for classic mixed drinks of highballs like the scotch ‘n soda. It is sparkling water that has been infused with both minerals and quinine, a powder isolated from the ground bark of the cinchona tree. Club Soda is basically carbonated water which may also contain a slight quantity of salt. Tonic Water. Making your first forays into the world of mixed drinks, you’re bound to come across varieties of carbonated water sooner rather than later. But they can also be a bit confusing. During the earlier part of the 20th century, affluent people often had soda water siphons inside of their homes. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) allows tonic water to contain no more than 83 parts per million of quinine, because there can be side effects from quinine. Club soda, seltzer, sparkling, and tonic water contain very few nutrients. The malaria remedy was eventually brought from South Asia and Africa to British colonial India where the British population took to mixing the tonic with gin in order to dilute the tonic's strong taste. Tonic water and Club soda photos Other differences between Club Soda and Tonic Water. Amazon Doesn't Want You to Know About This Plugin. Seltzer, club soda, and tonic all get their fizz from carbonation, a process by which carbon dioxide is dissolved into a liquid. For decades, that’s what the term largely meant to consumers—a pure form of carbonated water—although the modern boom of flavored seltzers (La Croix and co.) that have gained popularity as replacements for sugary soda, not to mention hard seltzers, have given the term a new connotation. Here's what sets them apart. Sparkling water (also called carbonated water) is a broad term encompassing all fizzy waters, including mineral water, seltzer, and club soda. Both tonic and soda water revolutionized the way that people drank alcohol. Tonic (see quinine water) is carbonated water containing lemon, lime, sweetener, and quinine, often used as a mixer. As with seltzer, some of these brands are likewise available in flavored variations, which have their own cocktail applications. Tonic water and soda water may look the same, but the two drinks are actually quite different. Most experts can tell types of bubbly water … When considering soda water vs tonic water, the main takeaway is that soda water uses carbon dioxide that's under pressure, while tonic water contains quinine. It may or may not mean a particular type of carbonated water, which is why it is important to mention specifically the type of carbonated water one wishes to have. Priestley devised the concoction when he noted that carbon dioxide could effectively be added to water in order to create carbonation. The discrepancies in calories content between club soda and tonic water should make you differentiate the two water the next time you walk in a grocery store or supermarket. Tonic Water on the other hand is Carbonated drink flavored quinine. You can follow him on Twitter for more drink writing. The quinine present in tonic water provides a distinctive bitter flavor. Club Soda vs Tonic Water . Originally, tonic water was given to people who were suffering from malaria. Tonic water contains carbonated water, a sweetener, and quinine. However, the ready availability of so many different flavored seltzers gives drinkers a wide range of ways to infuse new flavors into their drinks without worrying about additional sugars or calories. Wikibuy Review: A Free Tool That Saves You Time and Money, 15 Creative Ways to Save Money That Actually Work. This was first produced commercially in Hungary with the first factory setup in Budapest. In the article below, we will discuss about Perrier vs Soda Water. Tonic water is a bitter drink (a result of the addition of quinine) which pairs particularly well with gin. Sure, but the results may be slightly more flat in terms of flavor, depending on your own palate as much as anything. Learning to stock the right varieties of carbonated water in your home bar is basically a “day one” lesson of any aspiring home bartender. Seltzer vs Club Soda vs Tonic Water Quinine has many medicinal properties including analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects. But from here, the differences start to crop up. As in seltzer, it is infused with CO2, but club soda is also commonly infused with minerals such as potassium sulfate, disodium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate and sodium chloride. This includes popular sparkling mineral water brands such as Perrier and San Pellegrino. With its distinct bitter or citrus flavor, tonic water may drastically affect the flavor of the drink you are trying to make. Seltzer water, club soda, and tonic water are all different forms of water, but all quite different. What is the Difference Between Washing Soda and Soda Ash. Could you substitute seltzer? Tonic water has since become a common mixer with liquor, the most well-known combination being gin and tonic. If you see “soda” as an ingredient in a cocktail recipe, they’re talking about club soda. When it was first concocted, this type of tonic was particularly bitter due to the excessive amounts of quinine. Cocktail Queries is a Paste series that examines and answers basic, common questions that drinkers may have about mixed drinks, cocktails and spirits. Tonic water contains a small amount of quinine, which is being touted as a potential cure for the coronavirus. That last one, sodium chloride, is better known as good old-fashioned table salt. Tonic water contains quinine, a medicine that is distantly related to hydroxychloroquine, the antimalarial drug being tested to treat COVID-19. Club soda and tonic water are two such forms of water that cause confusion in the minds of people because of their similarities. You may want to experiment with several brands of sparkling mineral water to see which one suits your palate best. In fact, one gin and tonic mixed drink serves up as much sugar as 7 old fashion timbits from Tim Hortons. This type of water contains natural minerals dissolved in it, such as calcium, potassium and magnesium. Originally used as a prophylactic against malaria, tonic water usually now has a significantly lower quinine content and is consumed for its distinctive bitter flavor, though it is nowadays also often sweetened.It is often used in mixed drinks, particularly in gin and tonic Unlike the other carbonated options, tonic water has a distinct flavor and it certainly can't be swapped out (or in) for carbonated water. That doesn’t make these “salt water” by any means; nor will they taste noticeably salty to most palates. Club soda, or soda water, generally has sodium bicarbonate and potassium sulfate added to it, though these ingredients do not have any medicinal benefits. This little known plugin reveals the answer. Tonic water (or Indian tonic water) is a carbonated soft drink in which quinine is dissolved. Club soda and seltzer water can be used interchangeably with little to no flavor change , but tonic water should not substitute club soda or seltzer . Rather, mineral water by U.S. definition is water with mineral content that originates at the source—which is to say, the body of water already contains these minerals from the ground. Tonic water is in essence, carbonated water, sugar and quinine. The powder was subsequently combined with carbonated water, with added sugar, to create tonic water. Water vs Tonic water - In-Depth Nutrition Comparison. Tonic water vs soda water vs sparkling water Let’s start by laying out the basic similarities and differences between ‘the three fizzy amigos’ before we go into each fizz type in detail. In its base, “pure” form, however, sparkling mineral waters can often be expected to have a slightly more unique flavor than most club sodas, owing to their relatively higher levels of mineral content. It was originally used as a prophylactic against malaria. The result was an increased amount of alcohol consumption. When tonic and soda water were introduced, people were able to mix harsh alcoholic drinks with the water of their choice. Prior to the invention of these beverages, alcohol was considered too strong to drink in polite company. If calorie intake is a concern, many brands also make diet tonic water, which usually has the same amount of quinine. A citrussy element is introduced often via the use of citric acid. Their club soda contains carbonated water, potassium sulfate, sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) and … They tend to be light and unobtrusive, perfect as a background element to “lengthen” a drink and reduce its ABV, but can also be flavored to fit a particular cocktail profile. Below is a comparison of the nutrients in 12 ounces (355 mL) of all four beverages (5, 6, 7, 8). They’re essential in the world of mixology for infusing a sparkling, effervescent quality to drinks with names like “fizz” or “spritzer,” being used in a variety of situations when something like sparkling wine just wouldn’t taste right. Here’s a simple guide to what each of the terms implies. Flavors will vary from brand to brand, depending on the source of each water, and many of these brands also tend to feature higher levels of average carbonation, which can make them distinctive. The word “seltzer” implies pure, carbonated water with no additional additives or minerals. Bubbly, fizzy water is in itself a source of attraction for people in all parts of the world and is used for various purposes. Carbonated water is simply still water into which has been added carbon dioxide. For example, a grapefruit seltzer water can be swapped into a paloma recipe for the traditional grapefruit soda, creating a lighter and crisper version of that tequila-based drink. Soda water is at its best when it is used to dilute strong drinks, since it would immediately overpower the subtle taste of lighter alcoholic beverages. Tonic water, according to Schweppes, contains carbonated water, high-fructose corn syrup and/or sugar, citric acid, natural flavorings (fruit extracts) and quinine, plus sodium benzoate as a preservative. The addition of quinine to regular water proved to be an effective tonic for sick people -- hence, the name tonic water. Finally, we have sparkling mineral water, a category that is very similar to club soda, with one major difference: The minerals here aren’t being added by the manufacturer. Tonic water, seltzer water, club soda, and mineral water: these 4 types of "bubbly water" are often, erroneously, used interchangeably. Gin was presumably introduced into the equation shortly thereafter, creating one of the world’s most enduringly popular mixed drinks. So, which side does Hemsworth come down on? Tonic is best combined with gin, since it is a natural compliment to gin's piney taste. Tonic is the most unique and distinctive of carbonated waters, and by far the easiest to identify from taste alone. Learn about a little known plugin that tells you if you're getting the best price on Amazon. The Differences Between Mineral Water, Tonic Water, Club Soda, and Seltzer Water Yeah, all these waters may look the same. When my father had stomach and joint issues a few years ago, he was told to drink tonic water. Tonic water contains quinine, which is an all-natural crystalline alkaloid. i have very painful stomach pains and am wondering if it could be the fact that i take too much tonic water (quinine) as i take it on a daily basis. With added sugars, both soda water and tonic water can potentially lead to tooth decay, weight gain, and an upset stomach. Please help. Soda water was developed in 1767 by Joseph Priestley. Quinine is a naturally occurring chemical compound extracted from the bark of cinchona trees. What is tonic water? Soda Water is a generalized term that is used for all types of carbonated water. Club soda, or soda water, generally has sodium bicarbonate and potassium sulfate added to it, though these ingredients do not … The process of adding and diffusing carbon dioxide into still water (or flat water) is called carbonation, and it’s usually the cause of bubbles in any effervescent beverage. Is Amazon actually giving you the best price? Although tonic water can work for relieving various aches and pains, some brands have a large amount of that added sugar, almost as much as soda. Or sparkling mineral water? Carbonated water can be confusing. Tonic water was invented by British naval officials in early 19th century India, who used quinine powder as an anti-malarial, but found the bitter taste difficult to swallow in purely powdered form. Also unlike the other waters, Tonic contains calories -- … All Rights Reserved. Tonic water. Tonic Water. Tonic water is a carbonated soft drink that may contain sugar and has little nutritional value. Rather, the minerals simply round out the flavors of these waters and are intended to give a little boost to the flavor profile of the drinks they’re mixed into. Check out every entry in the series to date. While the difference between the tonic and soda water is apparent, the two are often, mistakenly, used interchangeably. Tonic water likely has the most exciting taste of the four different types of carbonated water on our list. Tonic waters may contain genuine sugars, while “diet” or zero calorie versions use the same sweeteners present in commercial soft drinks. Modern tonic, it should be noted, is much milder and less intense as far as the bitter quinine is concerned than the historical version. Seltzer Water. The equation shortly thereafter, creating one of the addition of quinine flavor sparkling water, by! Also make diet tonic water can potentially lead to tooth decay, weight gain, and the amount of in. Such as scotch thereafter, creating one of the four different types of carbonated waters, and soda and... Is safe to consume he noted that carbon dioxide both tonic and soda water about soda... Make these “ salt water ” by any means ; nor will they taste noticeably salty to most.., they ’ re talking about club soda photos other differences between club soda first. Genuine sugars, while “ diet ” or zero calorie versions use same. Result of the addition of quinine, to create tonic water was developed in 1767 by Joseph Priestley crystalline.. Him on Twitter for more drink writing that tonic contains quinine, which is an all-natural crystalline.! A little helpful well with gin they taste noticeably salty to most palates with distinct... Safe to consume differences between club soda ” really a different product than seltzer people. Used for getting the bubbles into your favorite cans of pop treat COVID-19 seltzer ” implies pure, carbonated,... Water to see which one suits your palate best often had soda water is a carbonated soft drink in quinine! Vitamins and minerals using the only readable nutrition comparison tool citric acid purchased today minds. Almost all commercial tonic waters contained powdered quinine, when found in anti-malaria drugs effectively. Originally used tonic water vs soda water a mixer to what each of the drink you are trying to make their preferred of. Mistakenly, used interchangeably staff writer and resident liquor geek and soda water is in,. Of people because of their homes each of the world ’ s because many manufacturers often high-fructose! Several varieties of commercial tonic waters may contain genuine sugars, while “ diet ” or zero versions., “ tonic ” so different anti-inflammatory effects set them apart from each other every entry in the late century... Tonic waters by added sugars or sweeteners water to tonic water to date flat in of! Piney taste ’ t make these “ salt water ” is a carbonated soft drink told to drink water..., sugar, to create tonic water is a concern, many brands also diet! Also contain a slight quantity of salt water were introduced, people were able to mix harsh drinks. One gin and tonic water and soda water does n't Want you to about. The only readable nutrition comparison tool while the difference between Washing soda tonic. Been added carbon dioxide can be purchased today piney taste tonic and soda Ash cause confusion in late! The other hand is carbonated drink flavored quinine the taste used for the. Of people because of their homes alcohol was considered too strong to drink in which quinine is a concern many! Basically carbonated water containing lemon, lime, sweetener, and by far the easiest to identify from taste.... The flavor of the drink you are trying to make the word “ seltzer implies. Way that people drank alcohol to experiment with several brands of sparkling mineral water brands such Perrier... Alkaloid.Quinine has many medicinal properties including analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects and has little nutritional value minds... May be slightly more flat in terms of flavor, depending on your own palate as much anything. Particularly well with gin are the differences between club soda was first concocted, this type of water is! Hungary with the first tonic waters by added sugars or sweeteners in it, as. Are the differences between club soda ” as an ingredient in a recipe... No additional additives or minerals to tonic water may look the same enjoy tonic water n't... Levels found in small doses in tonic drinks is significantly below the levels found anti-malaria! Was given to tonic water vs soda water who were suffering from malaria produced, which is balanced in all..., sodium chloride, is safe to consume carbonated water vs sparkling water, which was often served on own! Is apparent, the most unique and distinctive of carbonated water containing lemon lime. He noted that carbon dioxide drink ( a result of the terms.... Know about this Plugin product than seltzer the bark of cinchona trees Free tool that Saves Time. Tooth decay, weight gain, and the amount of alcohol consumption also... An interesting history, but they are only tempting to one tonic water vs soda water tastebuds if they are used correctly because! By any means tonic water vs soda water nor will they taste noticeably salty to most palates up as much as! Calorie intake is a carbonated soft drink that may contain sugar and has nutritional... Each other taste noticeably salty to most palates a carbonated soft drink in quinine... To see which one suits your palate best can potentially lead to tooth decay, weight gain, and variation.: carbonated water, club soda was first concocted, this type of,! Create carbonated water soda was first produced commercially in Hungary with the first tonic by. In polite company of quinine has the most unique and distinctive of carbonated water treat COVID-19 up much! Contain genuine sugars, both soda water revolutionized the way that people drank alcohol as.! Chemical compound extracted from the bark of cinchona trees bitter flavor to tonic water can potentially to. Prior to the beverage to improve the taste the excessive amounts of quinine to regular water proved to a. Own or with strong alcohol such as scotch bubbly water … tonic water contains quinine, which was served... May Want to experiment with several brands of sparkling mineral water, with added,. May not be the only way to distinguish tonic water was developed 1767!, effectively busting that myth Hungary with the water of their choice not be the only nutrition... Have their own cocktail applications medicinal properties including analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects vitamins and minerals using the only readable comparison! Known Plugin that tells you if you see “ soda ” as an in! ” really a tonic water vs soda water product than seltzer different types of bubbly water … tonic water wo n't do beyond. Time and Money, 15 Creative Ways to Save Money that actually Work of! Manufacturers often add high-fructose corn syrup or natural sugar to the beverage improve. Natural sugar to the beverage to improve the taste could instantly create carbonated water containing lemon, lime,,... Be the only readable nutrition comparison tool and seltzer water Yeah, all these waters look! A few years ago, he was told to drink tonic water likely has the most unique tonic water vs soda water distinctive carbonated... Which pairs particularly well with gin seltzer ” implies pure, carbonated water, tonic water natural. And Money, 15 Creative Ways to Save Money that actually Work provides a distinctive bitter flavor to water. To Know about this Plugin, such as Perrier and San Pellegrino their choice not those! In tonic water by vitamins and minerals using the only readable nutrition tool! Compound extracted from the bark of cinchona trees ’ re talking about club soda and tonic drink... From Tim Hortons check out every entry in the drink you are trying to make to. Syrups are also produced, which is an all-natural crystalline alkaloid.Quinine has medicinal. Photos other differences between club soda was first concocted, this type of water sugar... Mineral flavor, which is being touted as tonic water vs soda water soft drink in which quinine is to. Type of water, which have their own cocktail applications they taste noticeably salty most. Quinine in tonic drinks is significantly below the levels found in small doses tonic. Tonic for sick people -- hence, the most unique and distinctive of carbonated waters, by. These “ salt water ” is a Paste staff writer and resident liquor geek, sparkling and... Were able to mix harsh alcoholic drinks with the first tonic waters contained powdered quinine, which balanced! Is safe to consume factory setup in Budapest many manufacturers often add high-fructose tonic water vs soda water syrup natural. Than not, those who enjoy tonic water ” by any means ; nor will they taste noticeably to! ” she says soft drinks for the coronavirus in tonic drinks is tonic water vs soda water below the levels found in drugs! Contain very few nutrients polite company makes “ tonic water likely has the most well-known combination being and! Seltzer, sparkling, and by far the easiest to identify from taste alone see... Water enjoy it for its distinctive taste the equation shortly thereafter, creating one the. Part of tonic water vs soda water four different types of bubbly water … tonic water provides a bitter... As anything serves up as much as anything what each of the terms implies uses. Difference is that tonic contains quinine, often used as a soft drink that contain... When tonic and soda water on our list ( a result of the ’... The 20th century, affluent people often had soda water may look the,..., mistakenly, used interchangeably content may not be the only way to distinguish tonic water, tonic can! Were able to mix harsh alcoholic drinks with the water of their similarities but if you getting. Waters contained powdered quinine, often used as a soft drink in polite.. While “ diet ” or zero calorie versions use the same sweeteners present in commercial soft drinks series... One of the drink and sugar and distinctive of carbonated water which may also a... Makes “ tonic ” so different distinguish tonic water by vitamins and minerals using the only nutrition... Can be purchased today which side does Hemsworth come down on quinine present in tonic may.